OPEN MON. WED. FRI. NOON TO 5PM | $2,000 Minimum Transaction | FRAGRANCE & ODOR FREE FACILITY
The Spot Price Shell Game: How to Protect Yourself When Buying or Selling Gold and Silver in 2026
Gold & Silver Industry
How to protect yourself when buying or selling gold and silver coins and bars in 2026
Most people buying or selling gold and silver coins or bars have no idea they are being manipulated. One of the biggest problems in today’s precious metals industry is hiding in plain sight: the misuse of “spot price.”
After 19 years in the business, I have watched the industry change dramatically. A decade ago, most dealers operated transparently. They referenced spot prices from independent sources like Kitco.com, where bid and ask prices were publicly visible and easy to verify.
Back then, comparison shopping actually worked. You could call three different dealers, compare their premiums against the same market price, and make a true apples-to-apples decision.
That is no longer the case.
The Problem
The Rise of Proprietary Spot Prices
Today, many large online dealers display their own proprietary spot price ticker directly on their website. That is where the manipulation begins. When a dealer controls its own spot price, it effectively controls both sides of the transaction.
When selling to you, the dealer can inflate its ask price and then stack additional premiums on top. When buying from you, the dealer can suppress the bid price to pay you less for your metals.
Some companies make things even less transparent by displaying only one “spot” number on their website. That number is often the ask price, not the bid price. The actual bid price, which determines what you will receive when selling, may not be shown at all unless you specifically ask for it.
“The actual bid price may not be shown at all unless you specifically ask for it.”
The question most sellers never think to ask
The Deeper Problem
Why Comparison Shopping Has Become Difficult
If Dealer A advertises a 5% premium and Dealer B advertises a 4% premium, those numbers are meaningless unless both dealers are using the same underlying spot price. If each company is using its own version of spot price, adjusted in its favor to different degrees, you are not comparing equivalent numbers.
The premium may look lower while the actual total cost is higher. Without a common reference point, the comparison becomes misleading.
What to Do
How to Properly Compare Precious Metals Dealers
Before buying or selling with any dealer, ask one direct question:
The question to ask first
“What bid price and ask price are you currently using for spot?”
While speaking with them, have Kitco.com open on your screen and compare the dealer’s numbers to Kitco’s live bid and ask prices. Do this with every dealer you are considering.
Pay close attention to
- How closely their prices track the live Kitco market
- Whether their spread is significantly wider than Kitco’s
- Whether they clearly disclose both bid and ask prices
- How their pricing compares across all dealers you contact
Once you understand how each dealer’s pricing differs from an independent benchmark, you can finally evaluate premiums and payouts on equal footing. Without that step, you are comparing numbers that do not share the same baseline.
For a complete list of questions to ask before visiting any dealer, read our guide: How to Get a Real Phone Quote Before You Sell Your Gold and Silver Coins or Bars
Before You Send Anything
One More Step Before You Ship Your Metals
If you are selling coins or bars to a dealer, prepare a detailed description of your items beforehand, including the specific coins or bars, quantity, weight, and condition. Then ask a simple but critical question:
The question to ask before shipping
“After all fees, spreads, and deductions, what is my exact dollar payout for these items?”
- Get an actual dollar figure, not a percentage or formula
- A firm number committed to before anything leaves your hands
- Take high-resolution photos of every item before shipping
- Record video of yourself packing and sealing the box
- Documentation protects you if there is ever a dispute
Final Thoughts
The precious metals market should be straightforward, but increasingly, pricing practices are making it harder for consumers to know whether they are getting a fair deal. The solution is simple: slow down, verify the dealer’s spot price against an independent benchmark, and insist on clear payout numbers before committing to a transaction.
A few extra minutes of due diligence can save you hundreds or even thousands of dollars.